Three Strategies for Campaign Success
1. Map the Nonlinear Consumer Journey
Understanding the modern consumer journey is equally essential, as the path to purchase is no longer linear. Prospective buyers interact with brands across multiple devices, platforms and channels, making it vital to deliver cohesive and relevant messages at every touch point.
Diving into different layers such as geographic regions, media mix and devices can tell different stories of effectiveness. For instance, Urban Science®, an automotive consulting and data technology company, worked with an agency who noticed a specific demographic group in a particular market (ex., urban, coastal, rural) exhibiting vastly different purchase patterns. Those patterns accounted for a 10X higher conversion rate when compared to the broader campaign. Had the agency not looked beyond a traditional consumer journey, they wouldn’t have uncovered this insight. Knowing what works for a particular audience, such as how they receive a message, when they receive it and how often can help marketers pull different levers in the ecosystem to optimize campaigns.
Accurate, comprehensive and representative data is non-negotiable for creating meaningful consumer engagements that drive results.
2. Broaden Your Data Perspective
While first-party data is the gold standard, relying on it as the sole source limits a brand’s ability to capture the full picture. Comprehensive market insights are essential to understanding not just who’s buying but who isn’t — and why.
Brands that measure impact in context and evaluate their media effectiveness against market-level benchmarks — rather than internal metrics alone — can make more informed decisions and unlock greater return on investment.
Consumer research teams devote a lot of time developing buyer personas, which are useful, but throughout the past five years we’ve learned that automotive shopping doesn’t happen in a vacuum. Trends are essentially thrown out the window, and the best way to get your automotive brand ahead is to look at real-time market insights and adjust strategies and budgets accordingly.
For instance, a non-luxury brand that previously pulled in luxury shoppers, noticed strong defection patterns toward luxury brands. The brand used this insight and leaned into more personalized, creative messaging to highlight in-vehicle features and were able to improve its ROAS/general efficiency with crossover shoppers who want the look and feel of luxury without the price tag. Now, the brand is actively targeting luxury shoppers with this messaging and finding that sweet spot for on-brand conversions. To be truly data-driven, brands need to let the data show what you didn’t know — and then let it drive the strategy.

To be truly data-driven, brands need to let the data show what you didn’t know — and then let it drive the strategy.
3. Move Beyond Attribution
Attribution shouldn’t just be a “report card” for past performance. It should provide actionable insights to inform future strategies. Yes, sales measurement is important when evaluating campaign success, but it’s not only about checking the boxes — it’s about going deeper to find other areas of opportunity. “Brands could look at sales measurement and say, ‘That looks fine, let’s move along,’ but that doesn’t take you very far,” said Amanda Juip, Head of Sales – AdTech Performance at Urban Science.
Understanding which specific media strategies and tactics work along the customer journey and how each touch point led to the consumer purchase will provide deeper insight and inform your ad spend.
While some brands may be hesitant or reject the idea of using a sales conversion metric in more upper funnel campaigns such as brand awareness or opinion, they risk missing a big piece of the shopper pie. One notable example is an automotive agency’s programmatic team that found nearly a quarter (23%) of total sales came from upper funnel tactics. Naturally, an awareness campaign with high-impact creative would reach more shoppers, but it wasn’t until the agency’s programmatic team looked back through sales that they were able to tell a more complete story. Had they eliminated sales conversions during a brand awareness campaign, they would’ve missed a big segment of shoppers. This insight allowed the agency to refine its approach and achieve measurable ROI.
Having the right data and data partner – and one that is an expert in automotive – is essential for visibility on how specific strategies and market insights influence sales and consumer engagement, so automotive marketers and brands can optimize their campaigns.